Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to Key West Fishing Reports & Stories

AFRICAN POMPANO & SHARK FISHING TRIP

Smiling fisherman holding an African pompano after a successful offshore fishing trip in Key West

Amazing Multi-Day Fishing Trip in Key West with Jeff Wuest

Join Jeff Wuest for an incredible fishing adventure in Key West. This trip lasts multiple days and offers a unique experience. Enjoy the beautiful waters and catch amazing fish
At Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing Charters, we have built strong relationships with many clients. However, few go back as far as Jeff Wuest. Jeff has been fishing with us in Key West since 2002. In mid-October 2022, he came back again. This time, he brought a group of close friends. They enjoyed an unforgettable multi-day fishing trip in the Florida Keys

Chasing Mahi-Mahi… Then Switching Gears

The trip started with fishing off the coast. We were looking for mahi-mahi, a popular catch for sport fishing in Key West. While the crew covered ground and worked their spread with precision, the mahi bite was unusually slow. Instead of waiting for the quiet time to pass, Jeff and his crew made a smart choice. They decided to change their plan and go to one of our favorite deep-water wrecks. This spot is known for big predators and exciting action

Wreck Fishing in Key West Delivers Big Thrills

Once the boat was anchored over the wreck, the team used fresh-cut bonita strips as bait. That’s when things really got exciting. Day one on the wreck was full of exciting apex predators. It showed why wreck fishing in Key West is a must-do for anglers
First up was a tough sandbar shark. It put up a strong fight. You can learn more about it at this link: sandbar shark fishing. You can also visit this link for information on Key West shark fishing charters. The crew had a tough time with the bull shark. But the true highlight of the day came in the form of a A Trophy Catch: African Pompano on Day Two

The following day, the group moved to a different wreck in slightly shallower waters. This time, they opted to drop squid baits, targeting species known to patrol these mid-depth structures. The strategy worked when Jeff caught a beautiful 28-pound African Pompano. This was his first one ever
African Pompano are known for their shiny, silver look. They are also strong and quick. This was a true trophy fish, and Jeff decided it was worth commemorating with a replica mount. It was a proud milestone in his two-decade Key West fishing journey.

The Perfect Ending: Fresh Catch Cooked Three Ways

No great fishing trip is complete without enjoying the fruits of your labor. To wrap up their three-day excursion, Jeff and his friends took their freshly filleted African Pompano to Hurricane Hole Restaurant, one of the best dockside eateries in Key West.

The restaurant cooked their catch in three ways: blackened, grilled, and fried. This let everyone enjoy a taste of their adventure. Paired with cocktails, island breezes, and plenty of fish tales, it was the perfect way to end an already incredible trip.

Two Decades of Fishing Memories—and More to Come

Jeff Wuest has been part of the Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing family for over 20 years. His most recent trip was a perfect blend of strategy, camaraderie, and unforgettable catches. Whether you’re fishing offshore, battling sharks, or chasing reef species, fishing in Key West can lead to an epic day on the water
If you want to make fishing memories like Jeff’s, we are ready to welcome you on board. Book your next Key West fishing charter with us today and experience the thrill firsthand.


  • Posted in: