Key West Shared & Split Fishing Charters

Experience world-class Key West offshore and reef fishing without paying for a private boat. Our shared and split charters — often called “makeup trips” — are ideal for solo anglers, couples, and small groups who want the excitement of deep sea fishing at an affordable per-person rate.

Join up to six anglers aboard one of our Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing vessels and target mahi-mahi, tuna, snapper, grouper, and more. With trips starting at just $200 per person, this is one of the best values in Key West fishing.

What Are Shared or Split Fishing Charters?

A shared or split charter combines several small groups onto one boat, dividing the cost while still delivering a full, guided deep sea fishing experience.

You’ll fish alongside up to six guests under the direction of a licensed captain and experienced mate. Our crew handles everything from setting lines to coaching you through the bite. Shared charters are a great way to experience offshore fishing affordably, comfortably, and stress-free.

Many guests tell us their shared trips turn into unforgettable days making new friends from around the world.

Why Choose Our Key West Shared Fishing Trips

Since 1965, three generations of the Baumgarten family have helped visitors experience the best fishing in Key West. As a long-standing, family-owned charter company, we’re known for professionalism, safety, dependable results, and customer service that goes beyond expectations.

With decades on Key West waters and thousands of successful trips behind us, our crew knows how to make the most of each day offshore or on the reef.

What Sets Us Apart

• Affordable pricing starting at $200 per person

• Small groups (up to six anglers) for a better rotation

• Clean, comfortable boats with shade and restrooms

• Experienced local captains and mates

• All bait, tackle, rods, reels, and fishing licenses included

• Flexible trip lengths: 4, 6, or 8 hours

Trip Options & What to Expect

Each shared charter offers a unique style of fishing, depending on the length you choose.

4-Hour (Half-Day) Shared Charter

Great for families or beginners. Fish the reef and nearshore wrecks for snapper, grouper, jacks, and mackerel. This shorter trip offers steady action and beautiful scenery.

6-Hour (¾-Day) Shared Charter

Our most popular option. Head farther offshore to chase mahi, tuna, wahoo, and other pelagic species while still having time to work multiple depths and tactics.

8-Hour (Full-Day) Shared Charter

For anglers looking for a complete offshore experience. With more time on the water, you can target multiple species across different areas — from sailfish and large mahi to tuna and deeper structure species.

What’s Included

• All bait, tackle, rods, reels, and fishing licenses

• Professional captain and experienced mate

• Coolers with ice

• Full fish cleaning and bagging at the dock

• Restaurant recommendations for “cook your catch” dining

Bring your own food, drinks (cans preferred), sunscreen, sunglasses, and a positive attitude. Crew gratuity of 15–20% is customary and appreciated.

Catch Policy & Sustainability

We practice responsible fishing to help protect the Florida Keys ecosystem. Undersized or out-of-season fish are released safely. All shark species are catch-and-release only.

By choosing Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing, you’re supporting sustainable, locally operated tourism that keeps our waters healthy for future generations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need fishing experience?

No. Shared charters are beginner-friendly. Our crew assists you from setup to landing your fish.

How many people will be on the boat?

Up to six anglers. This keeps the rotation comfortable and ensures personalized attention.

What should I bring?

Sunscreen, sunglasses, a hat, snacks, and drinks (cans only). We provide everything else.

What if the weather is bad?

Your safety comes first. If conditions don’t allow safe travel, we reschedule or refund your trip.

Can I keep my catch?

Yes — any legal fish can be kept, cleaned, and bagged for you to take home or to a “cook your catch” restaurant.

Book Your Shared Charter Today

Our shared and split fishing charters are one of the most trusted and affordable ways to experience Key West deep sea fishing. Whether you’re joining alone, with a partner, or with family, you’ll enjoy great fishing, a friendly atmosphere, and a professional crew.

Reserve your spot today and experience why guests have trusted Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing since 1965.