Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to Key West Fishing Reports & Stories

BEST FISHING PIERS IN KEY WEST – AND WHY CHARTER FISHING MIGHT BE EVEN BETTER

a group of people on a beachWhen it comes to fishing in Key West, you’ve got options. For many visitors, tossing a line off one of the island’s scenic piers sounds like paradise. And it is—if you’re after a peaceful afternoon with ocean breezes and a cooler full of cold drinks.

But if your goal is to actually catch fish—and maybe hook something worth bragging about—well, that’s where charter fishing in the Florida Keys really shines.

Before we dive into why chartering a boat might be the better move, let’s look at the most popular Key West fishing piers and what you can expect to catch.

1. White Street Pier

Known for its panoramic ocean views and easy access, White Street Pier is one of the top spots for inshore fishing in Key West. This pier stretches into crystal-clear shallows where you can spot snapper, tarpon, permit, and even the occasional barracuda. Sight fishing is the name of the game here, especially during tarpon season.

There’s parking nearby, benches to relax on, and it’s open 24/7. Whether you’re casting for fun or just soaking up the scene, this one’s a local favorite.

2. Edward B. Knight Pier (aka Key West Pier)

Once a shipping dock, this historic pier now draws locals and tourists for fishing, photography, and that killer sunset view. You’ll often see grouper, yellowtail snapper, jack crevalle, and of course, tarpon rolling through. It’s a solid spot to test your skills—especially when grouper season in the Florida Keys is hot.

Bonus? You’re just steps from shops, food, and even a few charter options if you’re ready to take it to the next level.

3. Outer Mole Pier

Tucked near the entrance of Key West Harbor, this spot is hit-or-miss depending on cruise ship activity, but when it’s open, the fishing can be fire. Expect snapper, grouper, mackerel, and tarpon, especially near the deeper water at the end. Bring your A-game—big fish love this channel.

4. Southernmost Point Pier

This is the famous buoy spot—“90 miles to Cuba”—and while most folks come for the photo op, you can fish here too. Try near the rocks for mangrove snapper, or deeper pockets for sharks, jacks, and bonefish. Just be aware of tides and crowds, especially during tourist season.

5. Key West Harbor Pier (Navy Mole)

This one’s got the best of both worlds: a slice of Key West history, ocean views, and solid fishing for tarpon, barracuda, and jacks. It’s also a launch point for many of the best charter boats in Key West, so if pier fishing doesn’t get you what you’re looking for, it’s easy to pivot.

Pier Fishing vs Charter Fishing in Key West

Pier fishing has its charm—cheap, easy, and low-commitment. But if you want to make the most of your trip to the Keys, private charters in Key West offer a totally different level of experience:

  • More Fish, Bigger Fish: Charter captains know the waters inside and out. Whether you’re after tarpon, grouper, mahi, or sailfish, they’ll put you where the action is.

  • Top Gear: No need to haul your own tackle. Our boats are stocked with quality equipment for deep sea fishing, wreck fishing, and everything in between.

  • Comfort Counts: Restrooms, shaded seating, coolers, and even snorkeling gear make for a more enjoyable day on the water.

  • Flexibility: Want to lobster hunt, cruise the sand bars, or try a nude boating trip (yes, that’s a thing here)? Your charter can be custom-tailored to your vibe.

  • Kid-Friendly & Safe: Families love our crew. Our boats are safe, clean, and captains are trained to keep everyone comfortable, especially on family fishing charters.

Why Book with Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing?

We’ve been at it since 1965. With seven boats and a crew made up of three generations of Keys fishermen, Cowboy Cowgirl is the name locals know and visitors trust.

Whether you’re looking for tarpon charters, lobster fishing tours, or a laid-back snorkel trip in Key West, we’ve got you covered. And if you’re searching “snorkeling charters near me” or planning a Key West private fishing trip, look no further.

Ready to Go Beyond the Pier?

Come fish Key West with the pros. Let Cowboy Cowgirl Sportfishing help you reel in something big—and create memories that’ll outlast any sunset selfie.

👉 Book your charter now or give us a call at 305-304-2946.

  • Posted in:
Next Post