SHARED VS. PRIVATE FISHING CHARTERS: WHICH ONE’S RIGHT FOR YOU?

This crew of friends scored big on their private Key West fishing charter, landing a trophy wahoo and making unforgettable memories on the water.

This group met as strangers on a shared charter but left as friends—thanks to great vibes and a cooler full of wahoos from their Key West fishing trip.

So, you’ve decided to go deep-sea fishing in th Florida Keys—great choice! But now comes the million-dollar question: shared (split) charter or private charter? Both get you on the water chasing sailfish, mahi-mahi, tuna, and wahoo, but the vibe (and price tag) are completely different. Let’s break it down.

What’s a Shared (Split) Fishing Charter?

A shared fishing charter—aka split charter or makeup charter—is where you team up with a few fellow anglers, split the cost, and set off for a day of sportfishing.

Why Choose a Shared Charter?

• Wallet-friendly: Instead of shelling out for a full boat, the cost start at  $200 per person.
• Social vibes: Meet new people, trade fish stories, maybe even make a lifelong fishing buddy.
• Great for solo travelers or small groups: No need to round up a full crew.
• Same big fish, smaller price tag.

The Catch?

• You’re fishing with strangers (who might become friends… or at least decent net handlers).
• You go where the captain decides—no custom plans here.
• Space is limited, so be ready to share the rail.

Real Angler Take:

“I showed up alone, left with five new friends, a cooler full of fish, and a sunburn. 10/10 would without a doubt do it again.” – Mike, Key West

What’s a Private Fishing Charter?

A private charter means you get the boat all to yourself—no strangers, no sharing, just your group, your rules, your fish.

Why Choose a Private Charter?

• Total control: Want to chase sailfish all day? Done. Prefer bottom fishing for snapper? Go for it.
• More space, more comfort: Lounge, stretch, no elbowing for the best spot.
• Ideal for families & groups: If you’ve got 4-6 people, the cost can be pretty reasonable.
• Crew’s undivided attention: You get the VIP treatment.

The Catch?

• Costs more ($600-$2500+ depending on the trip).
• The responsibility of choosing the game plan is on you (or your captain’s expertise).

Real Angler Take:

“We fished at our own pace, caught exactly what we wanted, and the kids got a masterclass from the crew. Worth every penny.Would recommend to everyone” – Sarah, Key West

Shared vs. Private: The Side-by-Side Showdown

The Final Hook: Why Not Try Both?

If you’re in the Florida Keys for a few days, mix it up! Start with a shared charter to get your feet wet, then splurge on a private charter for the full VIP experience.

Fun Fact: Many shared charter groups end up booking private trips together the next year!

So, whether you’re looking to save some cash and socialize or go all-in on an exclusive fishing adventure, Southern Florida fishing charters have you covered. Tight lines, screaming reels, and epic fish tales await!

Now, which one’s calling your name?